‘We think it is telling that ISS is releasing a new ‘ESG-skeptic’ policy.’ So says an ESG expert from a leading consultancy, talking about a new comprehensive review of all ESG proposals since 2022.
That report, titled What do shareholders propose?, takes stock of shareholder proposals filed at S&P 500 and STOXX Europe 600 companies over the past two years (the full 2022 and 2023 calendar years) and offers 10 key takeaways, including the idea that proxy advisers are ‘too ESG’ for US investors and ‘too little ESG’ for their European investors.
So what does SquareWell Partners, the firm behind the study, mean by this? Essentially, its research shows that European investors appear more inclined than proxy advisers to support ESG proposals, according to the firm – something that Carmen Ng, E&S director at SquareWell, says has implications for relationship-building.
‘Companies might need to put more effort into their engagement with European investors in order to gain their support,’ she explains. ‘As found in our previous study for Harvard, European investors have, proportionally, supported or endorsed more environmental and social initiatives than their US peers. While climate initiatives appear to be more broadly supported, European investors appear to be taking the lead in supporting initiatives relating to biodiversity and social topics.’
ESG skeptic
Ng also points to the recent news that ISS is set to offer an ‘ESG-skeptic’ policy as an indication of a potential shift around support. Already, she says, there are noticeable tendencies around support for – or opposition to – specific trends from proxy advisers.
‘We noticed there are certain S&P 500 shareholder proposal topics that both ISS and Glass Lewis seem to consistently support or oppose,’ says Ng. ‘The data is not sufficient to say this is the rule, but observing the pattern and understanding both proxy advisers’ positions in general can provide insights into their likely stances on future proposals.’
Just how influential these big proxy advisory firms are – or are not – has been a topic of much debate for years and this is another area SquareWell examines in its proxy season review. Ng describes ISS and Glass Lewis as having ‘a lot of influence among investors’ in the study sample.
‘We observed a substantial rise to around 40 percent in average shareholder support when both ISS and Glass Lewis recommend for a proposal and a sharp decline to around 8 percent when both advisers recommend against,’ she explains. ‘This makes it very important for companies to secure support for management from both proxy advisers, whenever possible.’
Beware misinterpreting drop in proposals
As well as looking back over the past two years of proposals, Ng says ‘there seems to be a significant drop in shareholder proposals’ so far this year, describing the early 2024 data on S&P 500 firms as ‘quite telling’, though she cautions companies not to misinterpret the numbers.
‘All items under the ESG term are relevant but not all are material,’ she explains. ‘This is what we think is changing: we think investors will focus on how sustainability efforts generate returns and will hold boards accountable for this rather than micromanage companies.
‘Companies should not misinterpret recent trends and news coverage as investors not caring about ESG. We think it is actually the opposite: investors are becoming more sophisticated in understanding these topics and factoring [them in] as part of their routine investment process, rather than as an isolated exercise. Companies doing poorly on material topics – such as climate or human capital – will be challenged.’
Excitement is in the air as the fabulous 12,000-square-foot Clubhouse is taking shape at RiverCreek in Estero. Nestled on a more than 4-acre recreational complex, the Clubhouse at RiverCreek will be the hub of the communitys vibrant lifestyle and activities.
Residents will revel in year-round fun at the elegant Event Room for happy hours and social events organized by a dedicated lifestyle director. The Sports Lounge and Card Salon will offer spaces for poker, Texas Hold Em, Mahjong, and more. Homeowners can stay fit at the fully equipped fitness center or enjoy the Indoor Sports Complex for basketball. Outdoors and sports enthusiasts can play tennis, pickleball, or bocce on shaded courts. The resort-style pool, shaded cabanas, and cozy fire pit provide relaxation, while younger residents will love the interactive splash park and shaded playground for fun in the Florida sun.
The contemporary-style new homes priced from the $600s to $800s at RiverCreek perfectly complement the fabulous lifestyle found within. At RiverCreek, youll discover Esteros best new home value and enjoy in-style living with amazing one- and two-story home designs featuring a gorgeous selection of luxury standard features. RiverCreek offers a variety of floorplan designs ranging in size from approximately 1,900 to over 4,300 square feet and includes up to five bedrooms, master suites upstairs or downstairs, 2-3 car garages, and plenty of flexible living spaces.
This incredible new community has it all, offering a resort lifestyle that is second to none and incredible new home designs in a beautiful Estero location. RiverCreek, which is off the Corkscrew Road corridor and just east of I-75, is one of Southwest Floridas most well-liked communities. Residents here can access a wide range of dining, shopping, top-notch schools, and entertainment options.
Models are open daily for tours at RiverCreek. For more information, call (239) 308-4600 or visit GLHomes.com/RiverCreek.
About GL Homes
Founded in 1976, GL Homes is a uniquely American success story. Built by Itchko Ezratti, who believed that hard work, integrity, and quality craftsmanship would thrive in the marketplace, GL Homes has since grown into one of Floridas largest homebuilders.
Misha Ezratti, son of company founder Itchko Ezratti, is President of GL Homes and leads the charge in overseeing operations across the state of Florida today. Misha Ezratti continues to reinforce the culture started by his father, namely, that every employee and customer is part of the GL Homes family. Those enduring values are reflected in every home built by GL Homes today.
With a more than 45-year track record, countless industry awards and accolades, and, most notably, more than 100,000 happy GL homeowners, its easy to see how Itchko Ezrattis GL Homes has grown into a top luxury home builder across both Florida and the nation.
This news content may be integrated into any legitimate news gathering and publishing effort. Linking is permitted.
News Release Distribution and Press Release Distribution Services Provided by WebWire.